The Mara Dyer Trilogy (+ The Shaw Confessions #1) – Quadruple Review Time!

Prepare yourself! I waited until I finished every part of this series (that’s out as of now) before I decided to post the reviews. So here they are, from oldest to most recent.


The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer (Mara Dyer, #1)The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer by Michelle Hodkin
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

So the Mara Dyer series starts off with Mara (saying her name is not really Mara) writing down her story at the suggestion of lawyers. This is the only instance of this being mentioned, and I finished the first two books without even remembering this fact. She’s in the hospital after a building collapsed, killing her best friend Rachel, boyfriend Jude, and his sister Claire. But she can’t remember anything surrounding the events… and for some reason she thinks she did it.

Flash forward, and maybe possibly Mara can kill things just by thinking them. Maybe. But all of this is sidelined so much by a beautiful boy who is unkempt, notices her, and of course – has a British accent and is a “bad boy”(let’s throw in a bunch of heart-throbby future boyfriend duh’s in). And she’s at a private school with some snooty evil people who pick on her. And she hallucinates a bit (or does she?) At this point, I’m super intrigued with the story – how are these people dying? why don’t animals like her? is she seeing ghosts or dead people or are they real?… but I definitely feel like it’s a bit jumbled because of the way the school stuff is thrown in. And then Noah (the scruffy boy) pretty much becomes attached to her instantly, and part of me really just wants to facepalm. But you know, I’m a sucker. So I still like it all.

The first half of the book and the second half almost seem like different entities to me, with the first half being rated far lower than the second. I take it back – separate those into thirds, with the middle section being all over the place. But anyway.. by the end, you are faced with of course, a cliffhanger that draws you into the much BETTER and more organized second novel of the series.


The Evolution of Mara Dyer (Mara Dyer, #2)The Evolution of Mara Dyer by Michelle Hodkin
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Now this was jam packed full of fun. Most of the non-sense and jumping around from the first book of the trilogy seems to have been resolved, as Michelle Hodkin truly catches her stride. I managed to read all 500+ pages in a workday, so it’s definitely interesting.

Mara finds out more about herself (and others) in the second installment, and so many things that were not believed before become true now. You get to see a lot more of Jamie in this book as well, which is a delight. You’re also met with new (and old) characters and a whole new storyline. It’s got the continued nice smidge of romance and more mystery and thrill.

Definitely the best out of the three – you won’t want to put this one down.


The Retribution of Mara Dyer (Mara Dyer, #3)The Retribution of Mara Dyer by Michelle Hodkin
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This story is not quite like the other two parts, but just as gripping – maybe even more so than the second. It’s also quite a bit darker, as you get to see a new side of Mara that maybe she didn’t even know was there. May not be for the light of heart (or younger audiences).

If you’re expecting a lot of romance in this one, you won’t get it – but it’s totally worth reading because you really do not only discover a whole lot more, but you’ll be thinking about it every time you take a break from reading.

A lot of fans and reviewers say that the ending was perfect for the series, and that no more was needed. I on the other hand felt differently – I felt that there was so much left to be said, and so many questions. And so many new ideas that popped up in the end-story. Unlike, say The Mortal Instruments series, I feel like this series NEEDS more books. Yes, there is a “sequel series” in The Becoming of Noah Shaw, but that switches point of views, and I really think that it could have continued on as just being part of the Mara Dyer series.


The Becoming of Noah Shaw (The Shaw Confessions, #1)The Becoming of Noah Shaw by Michelle Hodkin
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Spoilers from the Mara Dyer trilogy.

So many things could have happened after the Mara Dyer trilogy, yet this was somewhat unexpected. I read a bunch of reviews saying not to even bother reading this, but I did anyway because I still had so many questions after The Retribution of Mara Dyer. It ended great, but there was still so much more. We’ve got all of these kids with abilities, with potentially even more out there. Mara’s changed, but we don’t know how much. And Noah’s dad is still alive. And then there’s Professor A. K. – definitely not a book of closure.

So then we get this new series that’s in Noah’s point of view. I’m excited about it, but then I realize that the Noah at the end of Retribution is not quite the Noah we see in Book 1 & 2. There’s no where near as much snark, sarcasm, funniness.. And I managed to get through 75% of the book before I realize that nothing really had happened. Sure, you find out a little bit, and you’re definitely still left asking more and more questions, but this is definitely one of those starts of the series where it seems as it could only get better – because that last 7% definitely made the book.

If you felt unsatisfied after the Mara Dyer trilogy, then you should definitely read this. Just know that you’re not going to get everything that you want quite yet.

View all my Goodreads reviews.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.